Appraiser Bob Speaks
History IS a good teacher…
Not too long ago, an unassuming man living in Milan talked his way to the political table by trumping up his resume and using scare tactics and innuendo to sway the voters; he was elected Supervisor. Once in office he closed access to government, garnered control over the finances and changed the lock on his door. Checks were written without board approval, banking documents went missing and financial reports were late (if ever) and always wrong and terminated relationships with the very people who helped him get elected.
NO, WE’RE NOT TALKING ABOUT VAN TALMAGE…
Some years back, before Mr. Jeffreys became Supervisor a gentlemen, very similar in his approach and speech to Mr. Talmage, made his way into local politics; his name was Vincent Scelba. But now, all too eerily, it’s as if this man, who was run out of this town on a rail, is back, look at the similarities:
Talmage, like Scleba, looks sincere and plays the “aw shucks” country boy
Talmage, like Scelba, smiles broadly but does little but mouth platitudes
Talmage, like Scelba, has little management skill
Talmage, like Scelba, preyed upon resident’s fears that “things were bad”
Talmage, like Scelba, and needed change” and a significant majority bought the ruse.
Talmage, like Scelba, has cut-off access to our local government
Talmage, like Scelba, fails to file monthly reports timely, and is always wrong
Talmage, like Scelba, writes checks without board approval
Talmage, like Scelba, has lost or altered financial information
Talmage, like Scelba, has changed the locks on his office
Talmage, like Scelba, has turned his back on Milan residents who elected him.
What else does Talmage and Scelba have in common? Well, he fought endlessly with the Town Clerk, claiming that she didn’t manage the office properly (although she’d been in the office for a very long time) he felt he needed to provide the oversight…sound familer.
Fortunately, the board at that time saw Scelba for the charlatan he was and worked in a bi-partisan way to forge ahead and meet the needs of the residents; too bad that this bunch has chosen to ostracize their longest resident member and allow those with no history and little experience to foist one horrific law after another on top of our townspeople, shame on them.
Why attack a sitting town clerk? Mrs. Gill is not up for election…YET. You see, Mrs. Gill is anathema to them. She is everything they despise. She has a long history in the community, raising children, working as a volunteer, and a long history of helping everyone. From their perspective she has got to go.Mrs. Gill, earlier as Deputy and now as the Town Clerk and has been through several administrations; she provides continuity and history and to some degree a conscience to the boards; all clerks have done this.
But this board wants, no needs her gone, because she stands in their way of their tyranny. To facilitate her end, they were priming Ms. Gelardi to ascend to the position. If they could create an impossible and hostile environment they could undermine her office with the help of Ms. Gelardi and at the same time publicly humiliate Mrs. Gill by complaining about all aspects of her position. In short, make her want to quit and then appoint Ms. Gelardi to the vacancy.
Their ruse was discovered, confronted and derailed.
Ms. Gelardi was let go for insubordination. Plainly and simply put, a deputy works at the pleasure of the Town Clerk, not the board, not anyone but the clerk. State Law has made it that way so that the vital function of the office can be managed effectively, without manipulation by the legislative body, the town board.
Their cowardly act at that Friday morning’s massacre of the clerk’s budget was unprecedented and should be attacked by everyone in this town who pays property taxes. If they fail to live up to the budget as presented to the public last November and which was taxed to you and I this January, what reliability will we ever be able to expect from this bunch.Resolve today to ends this tyranny at the General Election in November.
SUPPORT MILAN UNITED

7 Comments:
Incredible. I never refelcted on the similarity, but you're right on the mark!
Yes, both of their first names start with a "v" and scelba and taldmadge spelled backwards spell "ablecsegdamlat" which in swaheeliy means "tyranny" when venus is aligned with Mars! You've figured it out!
:-)
I was not at the meeting on Monday due to medical reasons, but I did hear what went on and I am extremely dissapointed in the turn out. Mrs. Gill was attacked by the board and by Mrs. Gerlardi. I have known Cathie Gill for years, and the things that were said about her by these people were terrible. As I understand it, Mrs. Gerlardi stated that she was fired because of the political party that she is in (that being the democratic party) is just nonsense. Mrs. Gill should inturn say SHE is being attacked because she is Republican.
Grow up people. Mrs. Gill has been in the position as Town Clerk and Deputy for a long time and is highly respected person who cares about the people of the town. This Board only cares about their agenda and and what they want to do, and not for the good of the town.
I am also dissapointed to know that people did show up at the meeting in support of Mrs. Gill, but knowone stood up and said anything. Why?? You guys are the same ones who said they would support her and you left her in the dark Monday night... I don't understand it. How do you think it made her feel not being able to defend herself against these lies that Mrs Gerlardi had stated. Mrs. Gill has put up with her for all these years and finally had the courage to do what was right for the office and town and that should be commended.
There are two sides to every story. Mrs. Gerlardi is a disgruntled ex-employee and of course she will say whatever it takes to make herself look good, but the fact of matter is she was insubordinate and that is why she was let go.
You are correct, ConcernC. Mrs. Gill was not able to defend herself as she was taking the minutes of the meeting. It was hard to say anything in her defense because Mr. Williams stated that they had good reasons to withdraw funds on a temporary basis, based on his knowlege of town law ; Article 3, section 30, #10-"any such deputy shall have such duties that the town board deems appropriate". Too bad he didn't know about the finer points of law regarding the Comprehensive plan that just became null and void by the state supreme court!
about your Talmage's State of the Town Address - please bring back Jack and let him take notes and write the report. Jim & Bobbi - your report is just plain silly. Jack has gotten this secretary thing down - bring him back - you are embarrassing - almost as bad as Al's Cathy lament.
At the State of the Town meeting this past Saturday, Van Talmage didn't comment on the Town Board's withdrawal of funds for a deputy clerk. Here are some excerpts with his comments regarding this matter as reported in the Daily Freeman-By Patricia Doxsey, Freeman staff
02/18/2007
MILAN - The Town Board has stripped the town clerk of funds to hire a deputy clerk, a move almost unheard of in town government.
The Democratic board took the unprecedented step earlier this month after Town Clerk Cathy Gill, a Republican, fired her longtime deputy, Judy Gelardi. Gelardi had registered as a Democrat in October.
"The Town Board said we want to understand this in more detail, why it happened, what happened, what is the role of the deputy town clerk," said town Supervisor John "Van" Talmage. "So we passed this resolution until we could come to terms with all of that."
Talmage rejected Gill's assertion, saying "politics has no bearing on our side at all." He said he expects the Town Board to restore funding for the deputy clerk after it creates a job description for the post.
"If Ms. Gill agrees, we will probably restore the money," Talmage said.
Talmage said there is no time frame for that action to occur.
Perhaps I can assist the board-
Job Title: Deputy Town Clerk
Type: Appointed by the Town Clerk
Job Description: Appointed to assist with duties of the Town Clerk.
Responsibilities: Same as those of the Town Clerk.
Reports to: The Town Clerk
If this isn't the Town Board playing politics, then what is the problem here?
remember too, that Mrs. Gill is the one who appointed Mrs. Gerlardi!!
Post a Comment
<< Home